Becoming an eBay Top Rated Seller as a Beginner (Then a Transaction Defect Appeared)
I've officially become a Top Rated Seller on eBay.
Which is hilarious.
Because I'm a beginner.
I only started this business a couple of months ago, and half the time I'm still figuring it out as I go.
So I'm going to take it.
Except at almost exactly the same moment, two transaction defects turned up on my account.
Fantastic.
So here's what it's actually like becoming an eBay Top Rated Seller as a complete beginner, why the defects appeared straight after, and the full stock audit they sent me on.
Becoming an eBay Top Rated Seller as a Complete Beginner
I honestly didn't expect it this soon.
I'm a complete beginner. Before a beginner even begins, really.
I'm still learning constantly, and I'm still making mistakes.
I'm not completely sure whether Top Rated is a huge achievement or more of a "congratulations, you managed not to annoy too many customers".
Either way, I'm quite proud of it.
Because a lot of it comes down to customer service.
And that's the part I really want to be good at.
What eBay actually looks for
To be Top Rated on eBay UK, you need:
At least 100 transactions and £1,000 in sales with UK and Irish buyers in the last 12 months
An account that's been active for at least 90 days, registered as a business seller
A transaction defect rate of no more than 0.5%, associated with no more than 3 different buyers
No more than 2 cases closed without seller resolution (or 0.3% of transactions)
No more than 5 late deliveries (or 3% of transactions)
That's from eBay's own seller performance standards, and they do get updated, so it's worth checking them yourself.
Then the Transaction Defects Appeared
At almost exactly the same time I found out, a transaction defect appeared on my seller dashboard.
Two, actually.
I hadn't seen them before, so I don't know whether eBay had an update and added them retrospectively.
So I did a bit of digging.
eBay counts a defect when the seller cancels an order unexpectedly, for example because the item is out of stock.
And that's where the reality of running this business with severe OCD comes in.
Why OCD Makes Condition Checking So Hard
If you're new here, I live with severe OCD and agoraphobia.
Contamination OCD is one of my main ones.
I used to have a candle business, and I had to give it up because the OCD got too bad.
OCD is a genuine disability that I live with and work around every single day.
And for me, one of the hardest parts of reselling is condition checking.
I normally check my stock about three times.
Once when it arrives.
Again while I'm preparing and photographing it.
And again before it goes out in the post.
I'll steam it and make it ten out of ten before it leaves the house.
That's probably far more checking than most resellers would ever want to do.
And I don't mind that.
But occasionally, after all of that, I'll still spot something I missed.
A tiny hole.
A tiny mark.
And once I've seen it, my OCD makes it incredibly difficult to just package it up and send it anyway.
Somebody else might look at it and say, "Just send it. It's microscopic. Nobody cares."
My brain cares very much.
The frustrating bit is that if the item has already sold and I can't bring myself to send it, cancelling the order can affect my seller metrics.
I genuinely didn't realise that.
The Full Stock Audit (All 700 Items)
Rather than sit and worry about what else might be hiding in my stock, I decided to check everything again.
I've got 700 items listed.
So that was no small job.
It took absolutely ages.
I went through every single piece looking specifically at condition, as if I was the one buying it.
What I found
Three pieces went back in the wash. I just wasn't completely happy with them
Two items had tiny holes under the arms. I hadn't spotted them the first time, and they were mostly from my earliest boxes, when I didn't really know what I was looking for
Those two are no longer being sold as clothing.
They've been demoted to my craft materials pile, because we don't throw anything away.
RIP.
It's a little bit annoying financially.
But mentally, I'm glad I did it.
Now I know everything has been checked again, and I've reduced the chance of finding something while I'm packing an order.
And now I've got Top Rated status, I don't particularly want to lose it straight away.
Top Rated, then back to normal three weeks later.
That would be a very me thing to do.
Running a Reselling Business With OCD
I have to be realistic.
I want to run a relatively high-volume clothing business.
And I want to do it while living with OCD.
There are always going to be things I have to work around.
For me, that means checking more than most people would, being honest about condition, and catching problems before an item sells rather than after.
How Far It's Come in a Couple of Months
Seeing that Top Rated badge made me stop and look back for a minute.
I've gone from selling a few of my old clothes to see whether I liked it.
To setting up a business again.
To building hundreds of listings really quickly.
To my first 100 sales.
To becoming an eBay Top Rated Seller.
I've made mistakes along the way.
But overall, I think we're moving in the right direction.
What's Next for the Shop
The plan hasn't changed.
Reaching 1,000 active listings: still the main target
Adding more vintage: while keeping my costs low
Learning which premium brands are worth buying: alongside the cheaper everyday stock, which is mostly M&S, Next and George
Adding menswear as well as womenswear: which feels a bit like being thrown in the deep end, because I'm still learning the brands
And hopefully, this extra condition check means far fewer cancellations from here on.
One badge.
Two defects.
And 700 items checked all over again.
A Little Note About My Images ♡
You'll notice that the images across my blog are a mixture of my own photography and AI-generated images.
I'm a one-woman band running this little corner of the internet, without a team of photographers, designers or editors behind me. Living with OCD also means I can be particularly careful about things like copyright and image permissions, so I sometimes use AI to help bring my ideas to life without those additional worries.
Where possible, I love sharing my own photographs, especially glimpses of my cottage, garden and everyday life here in Scotland. Other times, I'll use AI-generated imagery to illustrate an idea or provide a little creative inspiration.
I believe in being transparent, so I wanted you to know that you'll find a mixture of both throughout my website. The words, experiences, opinions and ideas are my own.
Thank you for supporting my little one-woman blog! ❤️
Comments